See if this all sounds familiar. Alex Cobb was BABIP'd for 5 runs in the 4'th inning and Merrill Kelly shut down the Giants lineup.
Alex Cobb RHP- 5 IP, 5 H, 5 R, 2 BB, 3 K's, GO/AO= 10/1. ERA= 3.67. Generally speaking groundballs are a good thing for pitchers mainly because groundballs have zero probability of leaving the playing field. The downside is a certain percentage will get through the infield or become infield hits. If those groundball hits are bunched together, it can result in a very bad inning. All that occurs mostly at random. That's exactly what has happened to Alex Cobb too frequently this season and it happened again last night. Here is the sequence that produced the 5-run inning for the D'Backs: GB single, GB single, GB single, line out, walk, reached on fielders's choice, SF, LD single, GO.
Merrill Kelly RHP(D'Backs)- 7 IP, 4 H, 2 R, 0 BB, 6 K's, GO/AO= 10/3. ERA= 3.13. The Giants have faced Merrill Kelly 5 times this season. Here is his composite line for those games: 3-0, 1.53, 35.3 IP, 8 BB's, 30 K's, GO/AO= 31/23, 1 HR. As you can see, there is nothing special about the secondary stats. What stands out is the the extreme suppression of HR's on flyballs. xFIP would say that is not sustainable but he's done it for 5 games and 35 IP. Some of that is almost certainly a lack of power by the Giants lineup.
In fact, per Fangraphs, Kelly's HR/FB is 9.0% this season a full 3.6% lower than any previous season. His xFIP is 3.83 which is very close to his career ERA of 3.89. BTW, I don't have the time or inclination to do the math but his drop in HR/FB may be entirely due to the Giants lack of power in those 5 games against him.
Mike Yastrzemski RF- 2 for 3, 2B, HR(15). BA= .213. YtY is 8 for 21 with 3 HR's over his last 5 games in a late push to be in the mix for next season.
Brandon Crawford SS- 1 for 4. BA= .228. Crawford did Crawford things on the field including a barehand grab and laser beam throw on a ball that ricocheted high in the air off Jason Vosler 3B's glove.
Thomas Szapucki LHP- 2 IP, 1 H, 0 R, 0 BB, 1 K. ERA= 9.00. The Giants have rebuilt the lefhanded side of their bullpen on the fly. Szapucki has the stuff and has had strong appearances but has struggled with inconsistency. At this point, Scott Alexander LHP, Alex Young LHP and Jarlin Garcia LHP would seem to be ahead of him on the depth chart.
Jharel Cotton RHP- 1 IP, 1 H, 0 R, 1 BB, 3 K's. ERA= 2.56. Jharel Cotton would seem to have an inside track to next year's roster. He is arbitration eligible. Look for the Giants to resign him before he gets to arbitration. BTW, Shelby Miller RHP is a free agent, unless the Giants signed him to one of those late season deals that extend to the following season as they have done with several other players in the FZ era.
*************************************************************************************
Churn Watch:
The Giants placed Luis Gonzalez OF on the IL with a bad back which effectively ends his season. They recalled Ford Proctor C/IF from AAA Sacramento(he was on the 40-man roster). The thing Proctor has going for him is the ability to play multiple positions including C. Oh, and he bats LH. He made his MLB debut playing 2B and went 0 for 3 with his family watching from the stands.
*************************************************************************************
Scott Alexander is listed as the Opener for a bullpen game as the Giants try for a series win this afternoon against Drey Jameson RHP who has been sensational in 2 MLB starts.
***********************************************************************************
Question-With the shift being eliminated in next year's rule change, will this create more GB singles when Alex Cobb is pitching? It seems logical that hitters will get more GB singles unless somehow Cobb has had hitters going the other way against him to beat the shift. Not sure if that is the case. As the Giants have him signed for two more years (with a buyout option for 2024), I personally think he will be an asset to the Giants moving forward and that his numbers will improve.
ReplyDeleteIn general BABIP's have gone down since teams started shifting. On the other hand, it's my understanding the Giants are less extreme in their shifting than many teams so the new rules may not impact Cobb too much.
DeleteFangraphs has a discussion of this with a graph of Leaguewide BABIP against the Shift since 2010. The gist is, with ups and downs, it is (was) heading down.
Deletehttps://blogs.fangraphs.com/the-2023-rule-changes-are-here-and-theyre-all-good/
SF needs hitters!
ReplyDeleteComparing individual and team BA, OBP, SLG, OPS year-over-year (2022/2021) is distressing. No amount of pitching improvements can remedy that. Help, yes, but solve, no.
There was no significant effort to significantly improve or backstop hitting in the 2022-2023 off-season. Pederson was some improvement over Dickerson but not over Bryant. Estrada is good but not an improvement over Solano’s 2022.
Going forward and depending on Longoria, Pederson, Slater, YtY, Wade, Flores, Belt, Gonzalez, Estrada, and even Crawford is futile.
Flores and Crawford are signed, Estrada and Slater are inexpensive and useful but 5 new bats and up the middle defensive strength are needed.
The Yankees, Dodgers, and Mets are unlikely to let some sure fixes (Judge, Turner, Nimmo) go and those GM’/owners have the resources and desire to hang on to them.
FZ will earn his pay this off-season - let's hope Johnson and cohorts let him.
Anonymously Theseus...
DeleteAll of those are players who FZ has indicated he has interest in bringing back. The problem is if all of them are back, where is the room on the roster for upgrades?
Delete