AAA: Sacramento River Cats vs Sugarland Space Cowboys canceled due to rain.
AA: Richmond Flying Squirrels outlasted the Harrisburg Senators 5-4.
"When the Giants Come to Town..." is my blog intended to chronicle my thoughts on San Francisco Giants baseball. My special interest is in prospects and the farm system, but of course, will comment on all aspects of the San Francisco Giants. I will also comment on baseball in general, particularly from a fantasy baseball perspective. I hope you will find the site informative, and invite you to join in the discussion.
AAA: Sacramento River Cats vs Sugarland Space Cowboys canceled due to rain.
AA: Richmond Flying Squirrels outlasted the Harrisburg Senators 5-4.
Logan Webb limited the Cubs to an unearned run through 8 innings and got enough run support to even his W-L record at 4-4. Key Lines:
Matt Chapman 3B- 1 for 3, HR(7), 2 BB, 2 R, 2 RBI. BA= .261. I like Chapman in the leadoff role. He is third on the team in OBP and leads in walks by a large margin.
Casey Schmitt LF/1B- 2 for 3, 2B, HBP, SB(6), R. BA= .276. Schmitt made a throwing error costing Webb the unearned run but made up for it at the plate.
Jung Hoo Lee RF- 2 for 4, R. BA= .331. Lee made a running catch to save a run and keep Webb in the game to finish the 8'th inning. He stays in second place in the race for the batting title.
Drew Gilbert CF/LF- 1 for 3, 2B, BB, R, RBI. BA= .229. Gilbert has struggled, batting .179 over his last 7 games.
Logan Webb RHP- 8 IP, 7 H, 1 R, 0 ER, 0 BB, 7 K's. ERA= 3.46. Last two turns through the rotation, Webb is the only SP to get through at least 6 innings.
Giants have a travel day tomorrow and start a road trip in Atlanta against the Braves on Tuesday with Adrian Houser RHP facing Grant Holmes RHP who comes in with a 4.05 ERA.
AAA: Sugarland Space Cowboys beat the Sacramento River Cats 5-1.
The Giants were beaten in every phase of the game in close to a replay of Friday night's game.
Lineup: 7 hits from 6 different players. Devers went 2 for 4 with double. Luis Arraez tripled for the only RBI. Drew Gilbert drew 3 walks and a HBP and score the only run. 0 for 7 with RISP. 9 LOB. Overall as feckless a performance as we've seen all season and that's saying something.
Pitching: Trevor McDonald RHP left after his 92'd pitch and was still in the 4'th inning. Reiver Sanmartin LHP came in and walked the lefthanded hitting Michael Busch to drive in McDonald's 4'th ER of the evening. He then struck out the righthanded batting Seiya Suzuki. Is it just me or are this year's Giants terrible at taking advantage of L-R matchups, at least on the pitching side? If you are looking for a bright spot, 4 relievers, Hentges, Walker, Dylan Smith and Kilian pitched a scoreless frame each while allowing a total of 3 hits and 0 walks, although Hentges and Walker both hit a batter.
Defense: Adames kicked a ball 8'th inning for his 12'th error, second highest among qualified shortstops. His Fangraphs Def is -6.1, worst among qualified SS's.
I don't remember a team with a bigger gap between the whole and the sum of it's parts and not in a good way. This is just a very bad team and it's not completely clear why. In any given game it's truly debatable whether the hitting or the pitching was worse. It's gotten to the point where Kruk and Kuip sound completely disgusted in game after game, making you wonder if they know things they aren't saying.
Logan Webb RHP tries to stave off a series sweep today facing Ryan Rolison LHP who comes in with a 2.25 ERA.
AAA: Sugarland Space Cowboys edged out the Sacramento River Cats 4-3.
In the euphoria of Bryce Eldridge's walk-off grand slam, it was easy to forget the Giants trailed in that game 9-1 after 7 innings. The team that fell behind 9-1 is the one who showed up for this game and when Eldridge hit another home run in the 9'th inning, the bases were empty. Key Lines:
Bryce Eldridge DH- 3 for 4, HR(5). BA= .316. Luis Arraez had the only other Giants hit for a total of 4. The rest of the lineup went 0 for 22 with a walk.
Landen Roupp RHP- 4.2 IP, 4 H, 4 R, 2 BB, 5 K's. ERA= 4.24. Roupp threw 105 pitches so by no means pitched well, but left the game trailing 2-0 with 2 runners on base, 2 outs and a lefthanded batter coming up. Which brings us to.......
Erik Miller LHP- 0.1 IP, 1 H, 1 R, 0 BB, 0 K. ERA= 4.58. Miller promptly gave up a 3-run homer to the lefty batter he was brought in to face after failing to retire a batter in his previous appearance June 9.
J. T. Brubaker RHP(3.00) pitched 2 scoreless inning. Sam Hentges LHP(1.74) and Ryan Walker RHP(6.06) added scoreless frames. Walker in particular looked like he had better command of a sharper slider after spending some time in AAA.
Trevor McDonald RHP tries to even the series tonight facing Ben Brown RHP who comes in with a 1.74 ERA.
AAA: Sugarland Space Cowboys shut out the Sacramento River Cats 2-0.
AAA: Sacramento River Cats edged out the Sugarland Space Cowboys 2-1.
The Giants scored 10 runs over the final two innings capped by a walk-off grand slam home run by Bryce Eldridge to end a wild afternoon game at Oracle Park. Key Lines:
Luis Arraez 2B- 2 for 5, 2B, R. BA= .327. Another day at the office for Arraez.
Matt Chapman 3B- 4 for 5, 2B, 2 HR(6), 3 R, 3 RBI. BA= .262. Huge day for Chapman as he continues his power surge.
Rafael Devers 1B- 1 for 4, HR(9), BB, 2 R, RBI. BA= .233. Other batters had bigger days but every run counted in this one.
Jung Hoo Lee RF- 2 for 4, BB, 2 R. BA= .338. Otto Lopez is 2 for 4 today and raised is BA to .343.
Bryce Eldridge DH- 1 for 4, HR(4), BB, 2 R, 4 RBI. BA= .298. A Star Is Born! Youngest player in MLB history to hit a walk-off grand slam(Roberto Clemente previously held the record).
Daniel Susac C- 2 for 4, 2B, R, RBI. BA= .309. Susac cooled off from his unsustainable start but is still an upgrade over Bailey.
Robbie Ray LHP- 5.2 IP, 7 H, 5 R, 0 BB, 3 K's. ERA= 4.42. Ray was having one of his better starts allowing 2 runs over the first 5 innings. Then, with 2 outs in the 6'th inning, he allowed three straight hits and another run. Carson Seymour came in and promptly allowed the two inherited runs to score. Seymour would go on to allow one of his own runs to score then 3 more in the 7'th to put the Giants behind 9-1, a seemingly insurmountable deficit.
Reiver Sanmartin LHP- 2 IP, 2 H, 1 R, 0 BB, 2 K's, 3/0 GO/AO. ERA= 4.50. Not a great line but the best of the afternoon for Giants pitchers.
The Giants get tomorrow off at home to regroup. They start a weekend series Friday against the Cubs with TBD facing TBD.
AAA: Sacramento River Cats edged out the Sugarland Space Cowboys 5-4.
The Giants used a familiar formula for futility: Failure to drive in runs and failure of the bullpen to keep it close in the late innings. Key Lines:
Full Season Leagues were all idle as usual on Mondays.
Logan Webb pitched in front of a gassed bullpen and it cost him a win and the Giants another crushing, late-inning loss. Key Lines:
Jung Hoo Lee RF- 4 for 5, 2 R. BA= .333. Lee is now tied for 2'nd place in the batting race trailing only Forever Giant Otto Lopez SS who has a .336 BA. Lee scored 2 of the Giants 3 runs on a night they left 12 runners on base.
Bryce Eldridge 1B- 2 for 5, 2B, R, RBI. BA= .287. Eldridge had an RBI and scored in the top of the 8'th inning but he also contributed to the run in the 6'th by advancing Jung Hoo Lee to 3B on a single. So Eldridge contributed to all 3 Giants runs.
Casey Schmitt LF, Luis Arraez 2B, Eldridge and Matt Chapman 3B had 2 hits each with Lee recording 4. In spite of 5 multi-hit games, the lineup managed just one run in the first 8 innings and 3 runs total.
The Giants used small-ball to get what should have been an insurance run in the 8'th inning with Eric Haase C bunted runners from 2B and 1B to 3B and 2B, then Jonah Cox PH/CF executed a squeeze to score Eldridge.
Logan Webb RHP- 8 IP, 5 H, 1 R, 0 BB, 7 K's, 7/3 GO/AO. ERA= 3.88. Webb threw 99 pitches in 8 innings and appeared to have something left in the tank. Tony Vitello went with Keaton Winn RHP who appears to be the dedicated Closer now. It's just that Winn appeared in games the previous two days going a total of 2.2 IP while throwing 41 pitches. He probably should not have been available to pitch. What were Vitello's other options? He could have left Webb in there to finish it or he could have gone with Dylan Smith RHP who recorded the extra-inning Save the night before and ended up getting the final out in this game. While I think going with his Closer in the 9'th is ordinarily what 90% of Managers would do, you have to factor in Winn's fatigue and the general lack of reliability the Giants have had from the Closer role. On the postgame show, Shawn Estes was visibly emotional while saying Winn had no business being out there and Webb should have finished the game while admitting it was a hindsight opinion.
Keaton Winn RHP- 0.2 IP, 3 H, 3 R, HB, K. ERA= 3.23. Just for the record.
The Giants try to shake it off tonight with Adrian Houser RHP facing Andrew Alvarez LHP who comes in with a 3.54 ERA.
AAA: Sacramento River Cats defeated the Tacoma Rainiers 5-3.
Matt Chapman singled in the designated runner in the top of the 10's and newcomer Dylan Smith held off the Cubs in the bottom of the inning for the Save. Key Lines:
Jung Hoo Lee RF- 1 for 4, RBI. BA= .323. The Giants scored single runs in the 1'st and 10'th innings. The sequence in the first inning was a walk to Devers, a single by Arraez, Adames struck out then Lee delivered the RBI single. The Giants only had one other hit the entire game before Chapman's RBI single in the 10'th.
Trevor McDonald RHP- 5 IP, 4 H, 1 R, 3 BB, 6 K's, 4/1 GO/AO. ERA= 4.15. McDonald threw 87 pitches in 5 innings but allowed just one run to keep the Giants in the game. He fell one inning short of a Quality Start.
6 Giants pitchers threw a scoreless inning each. Keaton Winn RHP worked the 9'th inning in a tie game and Dylan Smith got the Save in extras. It looks like Tony Vitello is settling into a patters of Caleb Kilian RHP working the 7'th inning, Erik Miller LHP the 8'th and Winn the 9'th.
The Giants try to get some sleep on the red eye flight home. They start a home stand against the Nationals tonight with Logan Webb RHP facing Miles Mikolas RHP who comes in with a 6.39 ERA. He pitched 4 shut out innings against the Giants on April 19 in Washington.
AAA: Sacramento River Cats defeated the Tacoma Rainiers 7-4.
The Giants took the lead in the top of the 9'th inning of a low-scoring game only to see it slip away due to another late bullpen failure. Key Lines:
Rafael Devers 1B- 1 for 4, HR(8), BB, R, RBI. BA= .243. Devers HR was into the teeth of a wind from RF that was blowing fly balls as much as 50 ft back toward home plate. The man does have power when he can reach it.
Jung Hoo Lee RF/CF- 2 for 4, SB(1). BA= .324. If I understood Dave Fleming and Hunter Pence right, the SB came on Lee's first attempt of the season. The first SB attempt......all season! The SB did not contribute to the scoring but Lee also took third base on a single by Bryce Eldridge which led to Chapman's SF to score the go-ahead run in the ninth. Oh! And Jonah Cox stole 2B in the same inning for what will hopefully be the first of his career.
Landen Roupp RHP- 5.2 IP, 3 H, 1 R, 3 BB, 5 K's. ERA= 4.00. Roupp was helped the the aforementioned wind blowing in but pitched well until running out of gas in the 6'th inning.
Caleb Kilian RHP- 1 IP, 1 H, 0 R, 1 BB, 1 K. ERA= 3.45. Kilian leads the team in Saves with 4 but Tony Vitello went to him in the 6'th inning. Maybe Kilian's role is high-leverage guy whether that is the 6'th or 9'th inning? Otherwise it appears Vitello is willfully working to avoid defining roles as Kilian and Winn have alternated roles for awhile now. Maybe that approach works on paper but historically it has not worked in practice.
Keaton Winn RHP- 1.2 IP, 1 H, 1 R, 0 BB, 1 K. ERA= 2.48. Winn entered the game in the 8'th inning with one out and nobody on. He retired the next two batters but then gave up Pete Crow-Armstrong's second HR of the game to blow the Save in the 9'th inning. The Giants failed to score in the top of the 10'th and Sam Hentges LHP gave up the game-winning hit aided by an error in RF by Victor Bericoto.
Reminder that winning 18-3 does not gain more games in the standings than are lost by losing 3-2 in extra innings. And another reminder that a bullpen down to two sometimes reliable relievers is going to cost the team games. This team cannot lose games they lead in the 9'th inning if they have any hope of getting back into playoff contention no matter how many games they win by double-digit margins.
Trevor McDonald RHP tries for a series win today facing Jameson Taillon RHP who comes in with a 5.13 ERA. And why on Earth is this a night game on a Sunday on the final game of a road trip after day games on Friday and Saturday?
AAA: Sacramento River Cats shut out the Tacoma Rainiers 4-0.
Most of the first two months of the season saw the Giants with absolutely nothing going right. Suddenly we see a team hitting on all 12 cylinders and wow! The lineup hit 7 home runs as they scored double-digit runs for the third time in 6 games in a blowout win over the Cubs. Key Lines:
Casey Schmitt LF/SS- 4 for 6, 2 HR(15), 3 R, 3 RBI. BA= .293. Schmitt sure looks like he is having a true breakout season. Did Heliot Ramos just get Wally Pipped?
Rafael Devers 1B- 2 for 5, 2B, R, RBI. BA= .243. After a hot May, Devers had cooled off in June but he joined the fun in this one.
Luis Arraez 2B- 2 for 5, 2B, SF, 2 R, RBI. BA= .326. Arraez gets his obligatory two hits. This was his 24'th multi-hit game of the season.
Willy Adames SS- 2 for 2, 2 HR(11), 2 BB, 4 R, 4 RBI. BA= .250. And just like that, Adames is on track for a 30 HR season. He has 4 in his last 6 games.
Bryce Eldridge DH- 2 for 5, 2 R. BA= .293. Eldridge is batting .481 over his last 7 games and .392 over his last 15. Looks like we finally have a Giants hitting prospect who will live up to the prospect hype.
AAA: Sacramento River Cats defeated the Tacoma Rainiers 7-3.
The Giants brought their hitting shoes and needed them to hold off the Brewers in a high-scoring game. Key Lines:
Casey Schmitt LF/2B/1B- 2 for 5, HR(13), SF, R, 2 RBI. BA= .282. Schmitt led off the game with a home run. He also made a highlight reel catch in LF. He's been the Giants best all-around player through the first third of the season.
Luis Arraez 2B- 2 for 4, 2B, SF, R, RBI. BA= .325. Luis Two Hits does it again.
Willy Adames SS- 2 for 6, 2B, R, RBI. BA= .244. Adames is hitting .298/.338/.529 over his last 30 games.
AAA: Tacoma Rainiers beat the Sacramento River Cats 5-1.
Victor Bericoto's solo home run in the 5'th inning was all Logan Webb needed to record a Win. Keaton Winn secures his first Save of the season. Key Lines:
Victor Bericoto RF- 1 for 3, HR(1). BA= .250. Probably would have been an out in Oracle Park, but Bericoto showed off the opposite-field power we saw in spring training. The Giants had 10 other baserunners in the game but this was the only one to end up scoring a run.
Logan Webb RHP- 7 IP, 1 H, 0 R, 1 BB, 4 K's, 12/4 GO/AO. ERA= 4.25. Webb did not allow his first baserunner until the 6'th inning and did not allow his first hit until the 7'th in an ace-level performance. Hopefully this is the corner he needed to turn. Maybe the knee was bothering through the first month and good health will let him be the ace the rest of the season. At age 29 and with two seasons left on his contract, if the season is lost at the trade deadline, do you move him for a prospect haul?
Keaton Winn RHP- 1.2 IP, 1 H, 0 R, 0 BB, 1 K, 3/0 GO/AO, Save(1). ERA= 2.30. Winn earns his first Save of the season, 5-outs and a 1-0 lead no less. Can we please give him a chance to establish himself in the role?
Adrian Houser RHP tries to gain a split of the series in an 11:10 AM PDT start facing Coleman Crow RHP who comes in with a 3.14 ERA in 3 MLB starts.
AAA: Tacoma Rainiers defeated the Sacramento River Cats 6-1:
Hey team! Back atcha. Buster Posey had his swing-for-the-fences trade blow up in his face as he had to watch Kyle Harrison LHP strike out 12 Giants batters while Rafael Devers 1B went 0 for 5 with 4 K's and the bullpen failed to keep the game close in the late innings. Key Lines:
Luis Arraez 2B- 2 for 5, 2B, 3B, R. BA= .323. Luis Two Hits keeps pumping them out. Hopefully there is a team out there who thinks an elite contact hitter who can play 2B is just what they need to get them into the postseason and/or beyond.
Willy Adames SS- 2 for 3, HR(9), BB, R, RBI. BA= .245. Adames is batting .321/.355/.786 over his last 7 games. His solo HR got the Giants their first run in the 6'th inning.
Bryce Eldridge PH/DH- 1 for 1, R, RBI. BA= .254. Eldridge came up as a PH in the 8'th inning with 2 outs and a runner at 2B. He smoked a single past the first baseman that left his bat at 107 MPH. Eldridge did not start due to the lefty SP but he is raking it and should be in their most, if not all, games.
Daniel Susac C- 3 for 4. BA= .323. Susac kept the line moving in the 8'th inning helping the Giants score their third run of the game making it a one-run game.
Trevor McDonald RHP- 5 IP, 5 H, 3 R, 3 BB, 4 K's, 7/1 GO/AO. ERA= 4.50. McDonald walked the first two batters he faced in the game and paid the price in the form of a 2-out, 3-run HR off the bat of Jake Bauers. Beyond that, he pitched pretty well.
The Giants first two batters in the lineup, Casey Schmitt LF and Rafael Devers 1B went a combined 0 for 10 with 6 K's. Brutal. Speaking of Devers, I saw him in person on Sunday in Coors Field. I know he had a good month of May but the man looks like a huge tub of goo. It's really debatable whether he is in better shape than Joc Pederson was.
Logan Webb RHP tries to get the Giants back into the Win column tomorrow evening facing TBD.
I am taking a few days off to catch up with a college roommate and some other friends in the Denver area. I'll be attending my first Coor's Field game on Sunday wearing my trusty Matt Cain 43 shirt. I'll be back posting Tuesday evening June 2. Go Giants!
AAA: Sacramento River Cats downed Reno Aces 12-5.
Trevor McDonald recorded the Giants first Quality Start since May 19 but it wasn't enough a the Giants were edged out for a sweep of the series. Key Lines:
Willy Adames SS- 2 for 4, 2 2B, R. BA= .243. Adames doubled twice from the lead off position. He scored once in the Giants 2-run rally in the 3'rd inning but got thrown out at home on another ill-advised send by 3B coach Hector Borg in the 8'th. Not Adames fault.
Luis Arraez 2B- 3 for 4, SB(5), 2 RBI. BA= .325. Luis Two Hits was at it again. He singled up the middle with runners at 2'nd and 3'rd in the third inning for 2 RBI. I love that! Unfortunately the entire rest of the Giants lineup went a combined 1 for 23 with a walk. In particular, Rafael Devers 1B and Matt Chapman 3B went 0 for 8.
Trevor McDonald RHP- 6.1 IP, 6 H, 3 R, 2 ER, 2 BB, 6 K's, 7/3 GO/AO. ERA= 4.34. McDonald stated his case to stay in the rotation with a QS. The unearned run scored when his replacement, Matt Gage LHP misplayed a ball on the infield that led to an inherited run scored.
Caleb Kilian RHP- 2 IP, 0 H, 0 R, 0 BB, 1 K. ERA= 2.22. More creative bullpen management from Tony Vitello. Novel use of the guy who is your current apparent Closer. Understandable since it was a 1-run game at that point and Vitello was likely desperate to avoid a sweep.
Giants get a travel day before starting a weekend series against the Rockies in Coors Field. Logan Webb RHP comes off the IL to start Friday evening facing Michael Lorenzen RHP who comes in with a ERA of 7.21.
AAA: Sacrament River Cats outscored the Reno Aces 10-6.
The Giants lineup showed signs of life but another failure to produce a Quality Start and subsequent bullpen failure doomed this one. Key Lines:
Willy Adames SS- 2 for 5, 3B, HR(7), 2 R, RBI. E(10). BA= .239. Great game at the plate but the E-6 set up the go-ahead unearned run and the HR in the 9'th was too little, too late and no cause for celebration.
Casey Schmitt 2B- 2 for 5, HR(12), R, 2 RBI. BA= Schmitt continues to rake. He started at 2B in this one facing the tough lefty.
Matt Chapman 3B- 0 for 1, 3 BB, R. BA= .234. First three batters in the lineup reached base 7 times in 14 PA's.
Rafael Devers 1B- 1 for 4, 2B, RBI. BA= .246. Devers laser beam split the gap in R-CF to drive in Chapman from 1B. He also struck out with the bases loaded and two outs in the 5'th inning.
Bryce Eldridge DH- 1 for 4, 2B. BA= .178. Eldridge started the game against a tough lefty and doubled in his first AB. He also hit the ball hard in his second AB.
Eric Haase C- 2 for 3, HR(3), R, RBI. BA= .286. Giants first two runs scored on solo HR's.
Tyler Mahle RHP- 5 IP, 3 H, 3 R, 3 BB, 3 K's. ERA= 6.04. Mahle was a gamer but this was the 5'th game in a row in which the Giants SP failed to record a Quality Start. That starts to tax the bullpen.
Trevor McDonald RHP tries to be the stopper and stave off a sweep in the afternoon series finale facing Mike Soroka RHP who comes in 6-2 with a 3.27 ERA.
Giants full season affiliates were all idle.
While several good things happened in this game for the Giants, they ultimately came up short in all phases of the game for another loss. Key Lines:
Willy Adames SS- 1 for 3, BB, R. BA= .235. We need to talk about Willy Adames' defense. He made his 9'th error of the season which led to 2 unearned runs for the D'Backs and probably more runs overall through a cascade effect. We are at approximately the 1/3 mark of the season. 9 X 3 = 27. Shortstops generally make more errors than other positions but last season Elly De La Cruz had the most errors of any SS in MLB with 26. CJ Abrams was second with 22. Willy Adames had 16. Before today, Adames was #21 among MLB shortstops for fielding percentage. That number is probably lower after today. Advanced metrics are even less kind. He ranks #24 with a Fangraphs Def of -3.1. Per the eye test, he makes a lot of excellent plays and looks like he is willing to sacrifice his body to make them. So what's going on? Has he lost a step? Is he having concentration lapses? Per statcast it looks like a loss of range is at least part of the problem which is not good because honestly, he just doesn't hit well enough to contribute at another position.
Rafael Devers 1B- 1 for 3, 2B, HBP. BA= .246. Devers is rightfully batting in the cleanup spot. He drove in both runs with a loud double. His defense at 1B appears to have improved a lot over the last few weeks. Today he ran down a foul fly all the into the old bullpen area.
Casey Schmitt LF- 1 for 4, 2B. BA= .295. Schmitt smoked a double off the LF wall but also misplayed a flyball to LF. He was not charged with an error but had he made the play, Adames error not have resulted in unearned runs and Roupp might have stayed in the game longer or at least left with a 2-1 lead. The combined error and misplay to start the D'Back's 5'th inning was the turning point in the game.
Landen Roupp RHP- 5 IP, 7 H, 4 R, 2 ER, 1 BB, 7 K's. ERA= 3.30. Roupp did not have his best command but he was hanging in there until the unfortunate 5'th inning. The Giants have now had just one Quality Start out of the last 6.
J T Brubaker RHP- 3 IP, 1 H, 0 R, 1 BB, 1 K. ERA= 2.96. Brubaker pitches mostly in mop-up situations, but has done a good job eating innings.
Tyler Mahle RHP tries to get the Giants their first win against the D'Backs on the season facing Eduardo Rodriguez LHP who comes in with a 2.24 ERA.
AAA: Sugarland Space Cowboys blasted the Sacramento River Cats 12-3.
Rafael Devers' grand slam home run in the 5'th inning broke the game open and the Giants hung on for the win. Key Lines:
WillyAdames SS- 1 for 4, 2B, BB, 2 R. BA= .233. I am not a big fan of Adames leading off but he got the job done today against a talented but inexperienced lefty.