Buster Posey did not wait around for a season postmortem to make his decision, which he obviously made several days or weeks ago. He's making a change in the manager's office. I gave my thoughts on Bob Melvin's tenure as Giants Manager last week so you know this comes as no surprise. The tea leaves became more ominous yesterday as Melvin stated that he had no assurances he would be back next season and expected to speak with upper management today. His tone and body language telegraphed that he did not expect today's conversation to go well and it didn't.
Having already written my thoughts on why I thought Melvin's time as Manager was up, let's turn our attention to who will replace him. As I have said before, I have little insight into who would make a good MLB field manager. I wasn't happy when Bruce Bochy replaced Felipe Alou which shows you how much I know. Speaking of Bruce Bochy, his contract with the Rangers is up, but he is coming off two consecutive disappointing seasons himself. To me, bringing him back is trying to bring back a time and place that will never happen again and it diminishes the youthful energy and optimism Buster Posey brings to the organization. Time to bring in a new perspective.
It's my understanding a MLB field manager has 3 major responsiblities: 1. Maintain a positive, united attitude in the clubhouse. 2. Manage the the pitching. 3. Hold players accountable and provide effective feedback. By all accounts Melvin was very good at #1. He didn't make anyone forget Bruce Bochy in his pitching management. If he provided effective feedback to the players, it was not evident to us fans.
I hope Buster will carefully consider the qualities he needs in the next manager and make sure he does his due diligence in finding that person. Ideally it should be someone who understands advanced baseball metrics and how to apply them to in-game management while at the same time being more aware of how to effectively communicate and get buy-in from the players so they know they are not being managed by a computer.
Some names I have seen proposed: Bochy, of course. Former Giants back up catcher, Nick Hundley. Guardians coach Craig Albernaz. Mark DeRosa. Former Marlins Manager Skip Schumacher. Giants coach Mark Hallberg. Again, I don't have an opinion which of these names or any others might be the best for the job. That's why Buster is getting paid the big bucks.